The Paradox of Eternal Security: Navigating the Tension between Doctrine and Reality
Isaac Megbolugbe
February 24, 2025
Introduction
The doctrine of eternal security, which asserts that once saved, always saved, is a widely accepted tenet in Christian theology. However, the teachings of Jesus and the complexity of human nature introduce a nuanced reality that challenges this doctrine. In this article, we’ll explore the juxtaposition of eternal security and the peril of those who appear to be serving God but may be rejected, as well as the reality of backsliders.
The Doctrine of Eternal Security
Romans 8:30 and Philippians 1:6 affirm God’s faithfulness in predestining, calling, justifying, and glorifying His people. These verses assure us that those who are born again are secure in their salvation. However, this doctrine must be balanced with the teachings of Jesus, particularly the Parable of the Weeds and Wheat (Matthew 13:24-30, 36-43).
The Reality of Backsliders and False Professions
The Parable of the Weeds and Wheat warns us that not everyone who appears to be a true believer actually is. Some may be “weeds” masquerading as “wheat.” This reality is echoed in Jesus’ statement, “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 7:21). This tension highlights the importance of personal responsibility in living a life of obedience and manifest holiness.
Conclusion
While eternal security is a normative belief, the practice of redemption is more nuanced. We cannot assume that everyone who appears to be saved is secure. Instead, we must emphasize the importance of living a life that reflects our faith. As John Piper notes, “Eternal security is a community project.” Our security is not just individual but also corporate, as we encourage and support one another in our walks with God. Ultimately, God’s promises assure us that the holy and sanctified will participate in the first resurrection. May we strive to live lives that reflect our faith, knowing that our security is as sure as God’s faithfulness.
